
(Photo courtesy of Apple Inc.)
Out of pure excitement, I have to write about the iPhone. Surely you'll have noticed by now, new is out after the keynote at the macworld. Besides all the other news and products like the Apple TV which surely has improved over its last presentation and the collaboration with Paramount for additional movies besides the ones from Disney, clearly the iPhone stole the show. Not unexpected for most, of course, but Apple clearly "overdelivered". The idea of the design, a big screen, was available on the web somehwere a couple of months back, but realized as a folding mechanism over the screen. With the tochscreen solution, usability surely improves.
But already there a some doubts about the concept: A Cnet journalist claims the touchscreen could quickly get covered in fingerprints, or worse, the display might break, rendering the phone unusable. While I can see the fingerprints as a possible problem, the latter is something that can just happen to everything. And with a developing time of over 2,5 years, I am sure Apple did some tests about long-term durability and ruggedness - of course it looks fragile, but is it?
What I am worried about more is that Apple did too much, created a product that is too good, and yet, is not. Surely the specs are amazing, the touchscreen is just great, the interface slick as ever, the usage of OS X on a mobile device a breakthrough regarding the smartphone capabilities. The package is great, but how do the indivdual components deliver? Are they as good as their standalone counterparts? In other words, is the iPhone a better iPod, better mobile, better smartphone, better internet device than what is on the market? Let's have a look at the iPhone as an iPod. Like Steve Jobs said, "this is the best iPod we ever created" and of course he is right. Who will want an iPod video after he has seen the iPhone? With a screen that size, there won't be much interest in the big iPod much more. But the question arises how many people actually use the iPod primarily as a video player. If i recall correctly, not so many people did.
But if I'm right on this, Apple has two design flaws with the iPhone as the iPod:
1) not nearly enough Storage space
My guess is, that everyone will want to use that nice big screen to watch movies and tv series and whatnot. What will you need? Storage storage storage. Now even with the 8 GB version, how much movies will fit in? With OS X on board, applications, images and music will already fill up a huge part of the memory. Everyone will have to decide if he wants to use the iPhone as a decent music player on the side, or if he wants to carry some movies and tv-shows around, as storage space is very limited.
2) not nearly enough run-time on battery
5 hours is all the iPhone will deliver when watching a movie. This is supposed to be a full-fleshed mobile phone, a device that is supposed to enable communication while on the move. A normal mobile phone will run days before it needs recharging, but after a long train ride or flight you just might not be able to make that one call you should be doing. Ouch.
So if you want to use the iPhone as iPod, cut down that huge library of yours, or just don't throw away your iPod. If you want to use the iPhone as a video player, better buy another one to talk with, as the battery will run out. If you want to use it as phone, congrats! You just bought the smallest tablet computer imaginable. But you didn't buy a phone. You should be hoping that NAND memory becomes cheaper and fuel cells smaller in the next years, or better months, or even better, weeks.